Example: Die freudlose Gasse - Revision history

Dbalzer: /* Encoding our findings */

2011-06-13T10:47:55Z

‎Encoding our findings

Dbalzer at 22:13, 22 May 2011

2011-05-22T22:13:30Z

Dbalzer: /* Further evidence */

2011-05-18T08:35:51Z

‎Further evidence

Dbalzer: /* Further evidence */

2011-05-12T09:31:58Z

‎Further evidence

Dbalzer: /* Further evidence */

2011-05-12T07:57:30Z

‎Further evidence

Dbalzer: /* Working from original sources */

2011-04-05T14:37:31Z

‎Working from original sources

Dbalzer: /* Working from original sources */

2011-04-05T12:21:41Z

‎Working from original sources

Dbalzer: Created page with "''From the TC 372 Workshop Compendium'' ==Working from original sources== {| style="float: right; border: 1px solid #BBB; margin: .46em 0 0 .2em;" |- | valign="top" width=..."

2011-04-05T12:15:21Z

Created page with "''From the TC 372 Workshop Compendium'' ==Working from original sources== {| style="float: right; border: 1px solid #BBB; margin: .46em 0 0 .2em;" |- | valign="top" width=..."

New page

''From the [[TC 372 Workshop Compendium]]''

==Working from original sources==

{| style="float: right; border: 1px solid #BBB; margin: .46em 0 0 .2em;"
|-
| valign="top" width="405px" |
<mediaplayer image='http://filmstandards.org/media/joyless-init-img.png'>http://filmstandards.org/media/joyless-commented.flv</mediaplayer>
 



| valign="top" width="405px" |
''The scenario''

Let us assume tho following: A DVD copy of a film arrives in the archive. Neither the provenance nor the label gives any clue other than that this may be a version of ''Die freudlose Gasse'', directed by G.W. Pabst in 1925.

Since the copy is viewable, we can inspect its contents and make some '''observations'''. Our observations will guide us in the descision whether to treat this as a separate '''cinematographic work''', as a '''variant''' of ''Die freudlose Gasse'', or merely as a new '''manifestation''' of the initial release.
|}

{| width="100%" style="background-color:#D0D0D0"
|-
| style="background-color:#FFE2E2" | ''Observation''
| style="background-color:#FFE2E2" | ''Relevant to''
| style="background-color:#FFE2E2" | ''Action''
| style="background-color:#FFF2F2" | ''Rationale''
|-
| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | Not the initial distributor
| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | Manifestation
| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | New manifestation
| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | Could be just a copy for foreign distribution.
|-
| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | Distribution title different from original
| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | Manifestation or Variant
| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | New manifestation, possibly new variant
| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | New title alone would not justify a new variant.
|-
| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | Mentions a soundtrack, original is known to be mute
| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | Variant
| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | New variant
| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | A major addition.
|}

<table width="100%">
<tr>
<td>Introductory text must have been written several years after
initial release</td>
<td>Variant</td>
<td>Possibly new film work</td>
<td>Could be a "film about a film". However, this
text and added music appear to be the only major additions.</td>

</tr>
<tr>
<td>Text on a sign explained on an inserted image</td>
<td>Variant</td>
<td>New variant</td>
<td>Minor addition, common in foreign distributions,
not enough to justify a new work.</td>
</tr>

<tr>
<td>Soundtrack clearly not from pre-1950</td>
<td>Variant</td>
<td>New variant (of a variant?)</td>
<td>Soundtrack cannot be compared to that from the
initial release of the variant. Conjecture alone may not
justify a further variant.</td>
</tr>
<tr>

<td>Intertitles replaced by translations</td>
<td>Variant</td>
<td>New variant</td>
<td>Translation alone does not alter the artistic
content. Therefore, no new work.</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>Tinting too homogenous for an original. Must have been
applied electronically.</td>

<td>Manifestation</td>
<td>New manifestation</td>
<td>Uniform monochrome tinting is a minor change.</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>Total duration just 60 minutes, i.e. less than half of the
original.</td>
<td>Variant</td>

<td>New variant</td>
<td>Apparently an abridged version, but neither a
trailer nor an excerpt.</td>
</tr>
</table>

@@ Line 152: / Line 152: @@
 We have identified two further variants of ''Die freudlose Gasse''. Using the EN 15907 XML schema, we can describe these as additional instances of the ''Variant'' entity.
-Here is a [http://filmstandards.org/demo/xml/002/transform.php transformed view] and the [http://filmstandards.org/demo/xml/002/fgasse.xml raw XML encoding] of our example. Note that the XML-encoded record has some information that is not yet visible in the transformed view. We will elucidate this as we progress towards the ''link-friendly catalogue''.
+Here is a [http://filmstandards.org/demo/xml/transform.php?src=002/fgasse.xml transformed view] and the [http://filmstandards.org/demo/xml/002/fgasse.xml raw XML encoding] of our example.
 |}

@@ Line 166: / Line 166: @@
 {| height="20px" width="100%"
 |- style="text-align:center; "
-|<span style="color:#808080"> • Previous: [[Titles and proper names]] • Up: [[TC 372 Workshop Compendium|Contents]] •  Next: [[Example: The Illegals]] • </span>
+|<span style="color:#808080"> • Previous: [[Example: Pancéřové Auto / Das Panzerauto]] • Up: [[TC 372 Workshop Compendium|Contents]] •  Next: [[Example: The Illegals]] • </span>
 |-
 |}

← Older revision		Revision as of 08:35, 18 May 2011
Line 138:		Line 138:
	\|}		\|}

		+	===Encoding our findings===
		+
		+
		+	{\| style="float: right; border: 1px solid #BBB; margin: .46em 0 0 .2em; margin-bottom:20px"
		+	\|-
		+	\| valign="top" width="405px" \|
		+	[[File:Cw002trans.png\|400px]]
		+	<br />
		+	<span style="font-size:8pt">
		+	</span>
		+
		+	\| valign="top" width="405px" \|
		+	We have identified two further variants of ''Die freudlose Gasse''. Using the EN 15907 XML schema, we can describe these as additional instances of the ''Variant'' entity.
		+
		+	Here is a [http://filmstandards.org/demo/xml/002/transform.php transformed view] and the [http://filmstandards.org/demo/xml/002/fgasse.xml raw XML encoding] of our example. Note that the XML-encoded record has some information that is not yet visible in the transformed view. We will elucidate this as we progress towards the ''link-friendly catalogue''.
		+	\|}

	{\| style="float: right; border: 1px solid #BBB; margin: .46em 0 0 .2em;"		{\| style="float: right; border: 1px solid #BBB; margin: .46em 0 0 .2em;"

@@ Line 144: / Line 144: @@
 References and Materials: Die freudlose Gasse
 * [http://www.worldcat.org/title/freudlose-gasse/oclc/434077881/editions?editionsView=true Editions in OCLC WorldCat]
 |}

@@ Line 137: / Line 137: @@
 The sequence shown here is missing from the British version described above.
 |}
 {| height="20px" width="100%"

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
 ''From the [[TC 372 Workshop Compendium]]''
 ==Working from original sources==
-{| style="float: right; border: 1px solid #BBB; margin: .46em 0 0 .2em;"
+===The scenario===
 |-
 | valign="top" width="405px" |
@@ Line 9: / Line 11: @@
 <br />
 <span style="font-size:8pt">
 </span>
 | valign="top" width="405px" |
 Let us assume the following: A DVD copy of a film arrives in the archive. Neither the provenance nor the label gives any clue other than that this may be a version of ''Die freudlose Gasse'', directed by G.W. Pabst in 1925.
 Since the copy is viewable, we can inspect its contents and make some '''observations'''. Our observations will guide us in the descision whether to treat this as a separate '''cinematographic work''', as a '''variant''' of ''Die freudlose Gasse'', or merely as a new '''manifestation''' of the initial release.
 |}
 {| width="100%" style="background-color:#D0D0D0"
@@ Line 70: / Line 73: @@
 | style="background-color:#E2FFE2; vertical-align:top" |
 Minor addition, common in foreign distributions, not enough to justify a new work.
 |}
-<table width="100%">
+===Conclusions===
-      <tr>
-      <td><p>Soundtrack clearly not from pre-1950</p></td>
+''Die freudlose Gasse'' was produced in 1925 and entered German distribution in early 1926. The present variant must have been issued some time after 1928 (when the distribution company was founded) or 1929 (when sound equipment became available in many cinemas), more likely in the early 1930s. It has been edited with the focus on a single actress, Greta Garbo, leaving out more than half of the initial content.
-      <td><p>Variant</p></td>
-      <td><p>New variant (of a variant?)</p></td>
+It could be argued that this is predominantly a hommage to Greta Garbo, using material from ''Die freudlose Gasse''. If this were the case, then it would qualify as a film work in it own right. However, none of the additions and omissions indicate that it was the intention of the publisher to create a new cinematographic work.
-      <td><p class="note">Soundtrack cannot be compared to that from the
-              initial release of the variant. Conjecture alone may not
+In summary, what we have here is a variant of ''Die freudlose Gasse'', manufactured in Great Britain after the introduction of sound film. At present, we know nothing about the initial manifestation of this variant (e.g. format, soundtrack, tinting). Since the initial release of the variant cannot have been a digital one, we must assume the existence of at least two manifestations (of which the first one may be lost and the second one is the digital publication).
-              justify a further variant.</p></td>
-      </tr>
+===Further evidence===
-      <td><p>Intertitles replaced by translations</p></td>
+{| style="float: right; border: 1px solid #BBB; margin: .46em 0 0 .2em; margin-bottom:20px"
-      <td><p>Variant</p></td>
+|-
-      <td><p>New variant</p></td>
+| valign="top" width="405px" |
-      <td><p class="note">Translation alone does not alter the artistic
+<mediaplayer image='http://filmstandards.org/media/freudlose-fa1.jpg'>http://filmstandards.org/media/freudlose-fa1.flv</mediaplayer>
-              content. Therefore, no new work.</p></td>
+<br />
-      </tr>
+<span style="font-size:8pt">
-      <tr>
+Excerpt from DVD: Die freudlose Gasse. Wien: Verlag filmarchiv austria, 2008. ISBN13: 978-3-901932-94-6
-      <td><p>Tinting too homogenous for an original. Must have been
+</span>
-      <td><p>Manifestation</p></td>
+| valign="top" width="405px" |
-      <td><p>New manifestation</p></td>
+Here is an excerpt from a DVD edition of ''Die freudlose Gasse'' prepared and published by Filmarchiv Austria.
-      <td><p>New variant</p></td>
+This film has been subject to several censorship cuts, both in Austria and in Germany. Unfortunately, the DVD edition gives no information about which of these cuts have been reverted from archival material and where this release differs from the uncensored original.
-      <td><p class="note">Apparently an abridged version, but neither a
-              trailer nor an excerpt.</p></td>
+The sequence shown here is missing from the British version described above.
-      </tr>
+|}
-      </table>

@@ Line 14: / Line 14: @@
 ''The scenario''
-Let us assume tho following: A DVD copy of a film arrives in the archive. Neither the provenance nor the label gives any clue other than that this may be a version of ''Die freudlose Gasse'', directed by G.W. Pabst in 1925.
+Let us assume the following: A DVD copy of a film arrives in the archive. Neither the provenance nor the label gives any clue other than that this may be a version of ''Die freudlose Gasse'', directed by G.W. Pabst in 1925.
 Since the copy is viewable, we can inspect its contents and make some '''observations'''. Our observations will guide us in the descision whether to treat this as a separate '''cinematographic work''', as a '''variant''' of ''Die freudlose Gasse'', or merely as a new '''manifestation''' of the initial release.
@@ Line 24: / Line 24: @@
 | style="background-color:#FFE2E2" | ''Relevant to''
 | style="background-color:#FFE2E2" | ''Action''
-| style="background-color:#FFF2F2" | ''Rationale''
+| style="background-color:#FFE2E2" | ''Rationale''
 |-
-| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | Not the initial distributor
+| style="background-color:#E2FFE2; vertical-align:top" |
-| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | Manifestation
+Not the initial distributor
-| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | New manifestation
+| style="background-color:#E2FFE2; vertical-align:top" |
-| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | Could be just a copy for foreign distribution.
+Manifestation
 |-
-| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | Distribution title different from original
+| style="background-color:#E2FFE2; vertical-align:top" |
-| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | Manifestation or Variant
+Distribution title different from original
-| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | New manifestation, possibly new variant
+| style="background-color:#E2FFE2; vertical-align:top" |
-| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | New title alone would not justify a new variant.
+Manifestation or Variant
 |-
-| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | Mentions a soundtrack, original is known to be mute
+| style="background-color:#E2FFE2; vertical-align:top" |
-| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | Variant
+Mentions a soundtrack, original is known to be mute
-| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | New variant
+| style="background-color:#E2FFE2; vertical-align:top" |
-| style="background-color:#E2FFE2" | A major addition.
+Variant
 |}
 <table width="100%">
        <tr>
        <td><p>Soundtrack clearly not from pre-1950</p></td>